Testimonials
Read what my clients are saying!
“We are so fortunate that we found Jonathan to help us market our property. He was referred to us from our agent in New Mexico. He met Jonathan and instantly new that he was someone we could trust. We were in no hurry and we never felt rushed. In the end we received a very fair price and we are able to stay in the home rent free for almost six months. We needed that time to find our new home in New Mexico. We would highly recommend Jonathan. He was perfect for us! “
Chandler & Susan G.
House Seller Closed January ’26
9364 Spring Creek Road
Amherst, WI
$1,230,000 • 5 Bed, 4 Bath, 4,179 Sq. Ft.
“Jonathan Horsfall was an outstanding realtor and a tremendous help in buying our new home. As a family transitioning from military to civilian life, we needed flexibility, patience, and clear communication—and Jonathan delivered on all of it. He was always quick to respond to our questions, no matter how small, and consistently made himself available. He went above and beyond by driving long distances to accommodate our schedule and ensure we found the right home. We couldn’t have asked for a more dedicated, responsive, and professional realtor. Highly recommend Jonathan to anyone, especially military or transitioning families. “
Drew & Cassandra Morelan
House Buyer Closed December ’25
1615 Killdeer St, Holmen, WI
$539K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 2,048 Sq. Ft.
“Jonathan was knowledgeable and helpful. He made sure the entire purchase process go smoothly. “
Bill & Jennifer Z
House Buyer Closed September ’25
E7376 Troy Village Rd, Spring Green, WI
$675K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 2,420 Sq. Ft.
“Jonathan was very informative, and very reasonable in addressing concerns with homes we initially suggested. Helping my wife and I to avoid wasting times with listings that wouldn’t have fit for us. When we found the right listing, it had been posted online for 20 minutes. Jonathan was quick to get us a viewing. The next day Jonathan was showing my wife and I the home and continued the trend being very informative. As a first time home buyer when I first new I wanted the home, Jonathan was an excellent knowledgeable coach. Jonathan also had a network to get us a fantastic inspection that my wife and I continue to reference as we check things off our home improvement checklist. Jonathan was ever present, ever available, and ever flexible. Jonathan was open to questions that my novice home buyer mind was inclined to ask, and if I was close to a concept Jonathan informed me of realistic standards and goals. My wife’s wishes were also advocated for, even so far as to the cleaning of the home before closing being done professionally. The seller’s agent was difficult at times, and unconventional. Jonathan was selfless in the pursuit of our home. Our family felt secure in the purchase, and supported every step of the way, and even after when we continued to have questions. I suggested him to my brother already, and would suggest him to anyone I heard was in the market for a home!”
Michael Bauer
House Buyer Closed June ’25
209 N Mill Street, Waupun, WI
$239K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 2,051 Sq. Ft.
“Jonathan had great judgement. Everything we discussed he was very knowledgeable in. Any questions were met with answers within 24 hours. Overall, Jonathan had an excellent attitude and great customer service skills.”
-James Shaw
I would absolutely recommend Jonathan as a realtor! He took the time to find places that would be just right for me. He is knowledgeable, kind, and trustworthy. He had connections/suggestions for multiple companies, which helped me out with the inspection and repairs that I needed to make on the home I purchased. He made the entire process simple and seamless. He was quick to respond, made sure I understood every step in the process, and had useful advice.
First-time Home Buyer Closed Oct ’25
N167 East St, Waterloo, WI
$305K • 4 Bed, 3 Baths, 2873 Sq. Ft.
There are no words to express how thankful we are with Jonathan. He helped us with all questions we had and went the extra mile to help us obtain our home. He didn’t stop at closing, he made sure everything was going well after closing. Would most definitely recommend him.
Home Buyer Closed May ’25
625 Robin Dr, Sun Prairie, WI
$420K • 3 Bed, 2 Baths, 1744 Sq. Ft.
We had an incredible experience working with Jonathan. He was diligent and attentive to what we were looking for. He went above and beyond to eventually get us our perfect home. We highly recommend him.
Condo Seller Closed Oct ’22
430 Cantwell Ct Unit D, Madison, WI
$220K • 2 Bed, 1 Bath, 676 Sq. Ft.
Jon was very helpful thoughout every step of the home buying process. I could tell he wanted to make sure the houses I was looking at were a right fit for me. Jon was very easy to work with and get in touch with through texts and calls.
House Buyer Closed May ’22
8189 N 54th St, Brown Deer, WI
$235K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1370 Sq. Ft. • 1st Time Buyer
Jonathan stretches professional and trustworthy to the utmost!! He kept us updated and well informed during the entire process. He was always available and provided quick and thorough responses. His articulate and competent ability to handle the many unexpected issues that came up, put him above and beyond. I highly recommend Jonathan to make a very stressful process smooth and enjoyable!!!
Condo Buyer Closed Nov ’21
54 Golf Course Rd, Madison, WI
$328K • 3 Bed, 3 Bath, 2440 Sq. Ft.
Never before have I worked with a Realtor that
represented both sides of a transaction.
Being a tad sinical, Iworried that one representing a
“Seller’s interest” would not be as open to
representing my, “buyer’s interest”. I was wrong!
After having a candid discussion of my concerns,
Jonathan explained his standpoint and how his
objectivity could support BOTH parties’ interest in traversing this transaction. While I won’t say that I will make a habit of hiring the same RE Agent for both sides of a transaction, I WILL hire Jonathan to represent me on ANY AND ALL sides of a transaction. I couldn’t appreciate him more!
Condo Seller Closed Nov ’21
54 Golf Course Rd, Madison, WI
$328K 3 Bed, 3 Bath, 2440 Sq. Ft.
Very professional and responds promptly on inquiries. He represented the property extremely well and would highly recommend him.
Condo Buyer Closed Sep ’22
N771 Waubunsee Trl #2, Fort Atkinson, WI
$500K • 3 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 2465 Sq. Ft.
He was amazing and such a relaxing laid back guy. Easy buying a house with him. Never was pushy or trying to make you make a decision on house shopping you didn’t want to.
House Buyer Closed Jul ’21
418 Haskin Dr, Pardeeville, WI
$236K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1200 Sq. Ft
Jon was extremely helpful during our entire selling
and buying experience.
House Seller Closed Mar ’21
7452 Blazingstars Dr, Middleton, WI
$725K 5 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 4133 Sq.
Ft. 1st Time Buyer
Jon helped me quickly sell my condo. He provided
great tips for showings and always kept my updated.
He gave great advice and Iended up getting more
money than I thought I would.
Townhome Seller Closed Jul ’20
5431 Patriot Dr, Madison, WI
$210K 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 1600 Sq. F
Jonathan is very knowledgeable of the housing market; friendly and easy to work with!
Condo Buyer Closed May ’21
6532 Cortland Park Dr, Deforest, WI
$345K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1763 Sq. Ft.
• New Construction
Our experience working with Jon was as good as it gets! He is very personable andall communications
ere extremely clear and timely. He was upfront,
direct, and very easy to work with. Any concerns or
questions we faced were immediately addressed,
and he always had helpful advice without us e
feeling anything was being pushed on us. We were
first time home buyers and I cannot tell you the value of having someone like him in your corner. –Joe and Becky
House Buver Closed Feb ’21
1408 Munzel Dr, Watertown, WI
$185K 3 Bed, 1 Bath, 1272 S 1st Time Buyer New Construction
Absolutely wonderful realtor, he guided us throughout the entire buying process. We did everything that he asked for, and he promised If we listened, we’d become homeowners. We cannot thank him enough for all the work he did to help us get into our home. He’s simply great at his work and we will always recommend him and he’s a 100/10 star review.
House Buyer Closed Jan ’22
310 Mill St, Fox Lake, WI
$170K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1222 Sq. Ft. • 1st Time Buyer
Jon helped me buy my first house. He was incredibly knowledgeable and made the entire process as stress free as possible. He was also extremely responsive and personable. I started out looking at a variety of different houses, and Jon was able to quickly hone in on what I was looking for. He ended up finding the perfect house for me.
House Buyer Closed Jul ’20
6623 Warner Farm Dr, Deforest, WI
$425K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1873 Sq. Ft. • 1st Time Buyer
